Maybe it's because I was in Homestuck-land for a large part of my stay in Tumblr (2011 to 2013), but I sort of overhear from the sidelines mentions of this "100% perfect vs 100% terrible" thing and it just seems subtly off to me? I know there's always some fans who will interpret any criticism as "you said it was 100% terrible! hdu h8!", but it felt like the tenor back then, at least where I was reading, was more leaning toward Nothing Is Above Criticism, Deal With It. Can things have changed so quickly? Am I just experiencing ageing-induced subjective timeframe compression?